Palate cleanser

What's wrong with this picture?

1. Nothing, if you're Long John Silver.
2. You should see the other guy.
3. I have nothing against her left leg.
4. It's a Hallowe'en party. She's dressed as Thanksgiving leftovers. (Two breasts, a busted wing, and one thigh.)
   

I can't even figure what they were going for.
From Photoshop Disasters.