Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Our newspapers is still failing

newspaper blackout poem
Originally uploaded by Precious Roy
On March 2, RealClearPolitics ran with its list of the Top Ten newspapers in trouble. By the time the list appeared, one of the newspapers on it, the Rocky Mountain News, was already gone. 

This week, Time magazine has weighed in with its Top Ten "tim-berrrrr" list. The odds are pretty good that by the time the next issue hits the stands, one of those will be gone. Let's compare:

1Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Philadelphia Daily News
2Rocky Mountain News
Minneapolis Star Tribune
3Philadelphia Daily News
Miami Herald
4Miami Herald
Detroit News
5San Francisco Chronicle
Boston Globe
6Detroit News
San Francisco Chronicle
7Chicago Sun-Times
Chicago Sun-Times
8St. Paul Pioneer Press
New York Daily News
9Los Angeles Times
Fort Worth Star-Telegram
10New York Daily News
Cleveland Plain Dealer

Hm. Two lists, twenty slots, but only fourteen newspapers named. It can't have been an easy story to write for either publication: It's not unlike openly speculating which of your aunts and uncles will die first.

I, in my amateur opinion, suspect the next to actually go will be the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, since Hearst is now openly weighing whether to close it outright or go online-only. It can't be a good sign that one of the links on their home page right now is a "tell us about your favorite P-I memories" solicitation. The Detroit News could surprise me and fold tomorrow, or they might be able to hang on for a few more weeks now that they only publish four days a week. 

If I were the average big-time blogger, I would be a lot more worried about this than they appear to be. Instead of congratulating myself for being right that Old Media didn't know how to make the transition to New, I would be wondering where the stories I link to tomorrow will come from.

All these newspapers are in trouble because... Well, they each have unique problems, but they all share two really big ones: (1) A whopper of an economic downturn kicked them in the gonads; and (2) they never really believed that the traditional daily newspaper could go away. The Business Insider is onto something when they calculate that for the New York Times, giving each of its subscribers a Kindle would cost half as much as publishing an actual newsprint daily. I'm hoping the all new, online Christian Science Monitor can show everyone how it's done.

C'mon, guys, it ain't whether to go digital, it's when and how. Change or die.


Anonymous said...

It is done:


Daniel said...

Ah. And buried in the middle of the article is a mention of the Tucson Citizen, which will fold Saturday.